A new randomized controlled trial in Clinical Oral Investigations compared the laterally closed tunnel (LCT) technique with a connective tissue graft against a free gingival graft (FGG) for single recessions in the lower anterior region. At 12 months the two did not differ significantly in root coverage, but the FGG group gained more keratinized tissue height and reported more pain at one week. The trial is small, 21 patients, so treat it as one useful data point, not a verdict.
Isolated recession in the lower anterior region is a familiar reason for a periodontal referral, and the choice of graft for that site is still debated. As of November 2026, a group of Brazilian researchers led from the Federal University of Uberlândia has added a head-to-head trial on exactly this site, and its results speak to a question your patients will ask before they agree to surgery: which option hurts less, and which one holds up?
What the Trial Compared
The study, by Oliveira and colleagues from three Brazilian institutions, including the Federal University of Uberlândia and Alfenas Federal University, was published online on 17 November 2026 in Clinical Oral Investigations (volume 30, issue 12). It compared two approaches for isolated gingival recessions in the anterior mandible:
- LCT group (n = 10): the laterally closed tunnel technique combined with a connective tissue graft (CTG).
- FGG group (n = 11): a free gingival graft.
Twenty-one patients took part. The authors recorded periodontal clinical parameters at baseline and at 1, 3, 6 and 12 months. They also scored healing with the Landry index, rated esthetics with the root coverage esthetic score, and measured pain on a visual analog scale. Finally, they used statistical modelling to test how the treatment and clinical factors affected root coverage at 12 months, and produced scenario-based predictions intended to support individual case planning.
What the Results Showed
According to the abstract, both groups improved steadily in root coverage and keratinized tissue thickness over the year, and the differences between groups were not statistically significant. Two findings separated the techniques, and a third pointed to tooth type:
- Keratinized tissue height favoured FGG. The FGG group had greater keratinized tissue height at every follow-up visit (p < 0.05).
- Early pain favoured LCT. Patients in the FGG group reported higher pain at 7 days (p < 0.05).
- Tooth type mattered. Tooth type had a significant effect on root coverage at 12 months (p = 0.046), and the best outcomes were seen in aligned incisors treated with FGG.
The authors found no differences in healing patterns, in esthetic ratings by professionals, or in esthetics reported by the patients themselves. Their conclusion is balanced: both techniques were effective, promoting root coverage and increasing keratinized tissue, with FGG giving greater keratinized tissue gain and LCT causing less postoperative discomfort.
That last point is worth pausing on. Esthetics can be an objection to a free gingival graft in the anterior region. In this sample, esthetic ratings by clinicians and by patients did not differ significantly between the two techniques. One small trial cannot settle that debate, but it is a reason not to dismiss the FGG on esthetic grounds alone for this particular site.
How to Read a 21-Patient Trial
Small randomized trials are common in periodontal surgery, and they are useful. They are also easy to over-read. With ten and eleven patients per arm, a "no significant difference" in root coverage tells you the trial did not detect a difference. It does not prove the techniques are equivalent. A larger trial could find a gap in either direction.
The tooth-type finding deserves the same caution. A p-value of 0.046 sits just under the usual threshold, in a sample this size. It is a signal worth testing in future work, not a rule for picking cases.
We reviewed the abstract and the Europe PMC record, as the full text is not open access. Details such as graft dimensions, flap design, recession classification and how pain was managed after surgery are not in the abstract, and they matter when you compare this trial with your own cases or with other studies.
Pro Tip: When you refer a lower anterior recession, send the periodontist your measurements of recession depth, probing depth and keratinized tissue width, plus an intraoral photo taken in the same position each time. Baseline records like these let both offices judge the result at 12 months against something objective.
What This Means for Your Practice and Your Patients
For general dentists in Toronto and across Ontario, the trial is less about choosing a technique yourself and more about the conversation before a referral. Be ready for two questions before a patient agrees to a graft: how much will it hurt, and will it hold? This trial gives you two honest points to share. Both options improved root coverage, and the trade-off the authors describe is real: more keratinized tissue height with FGG against less pain at 7 days with LCT.
That framing fits the authors' own clinical message, which is that the results support personalized planning based on expected outcomes and patient needs. A patient who values a wider band of keratinized tissue may weigh things differently from a patient whose main worry is pain in the days after surgery.
- Before referral: record the baseline and photograph the site.
- At the consult conversation: explain that the choice involves a trade-off, and that the periodontist will recommend one based on the site and the patient's priorities.
- After surgery: keep the recall going. Recession sites need the same plaque control and monitoring as the rest of the mouth.
Pro Tip: Put a reminder in your practice software to re-photograph grafted sites at the 12-month recall. Twelve months was the end point in this trial, and a matching photo is the simplest way to show a patient what changed.
EBIKO Dental will continue monitoring periodontal and restorative research that affects everyday decisions in Canadian practices. You can find our clinical supply catalogue at ebiko.ca.
Sources
- Oliveira JA, da Silveira MI, de Oliveira Alves R, Cirelli T, de Oliveira GJPL, Pigossi SC. Comparison of laterally closed tunnel and free gingival graft for isolated anterior mandibular recessions: a randomized controlled trial. Clinical Oral Investigations. 2026;30(12). doi:10.1007/s00784-026-07281-0. Europe PMC record (PMID 43043487).
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is a free gingival graft or a tunnel technique better for lower front tooth recession?
In a 21-patient randomized trial published in November 2026, neither was clearly better for root coverage at 12 months. The free gingival graft produced greater keratinized tissue height, while the laterally closed tunnel with a connective tissue graft caused less pain at 7 days.
Q: Does a free gingival graft look worse on lower front teeth?
In this small trial, esthetic ratings by professionals and by patients did not differ significantly between the two techniques, and neither did healing patterns. A trial of 21 patients cannot prove the two look the same.
Q: Why does this study have so few patients?
The trial enrolled 21 patients, 10 in one group and 11 in the other, which is common for periodontal surgery trials. A sample this small can miss real differences, so its "no significant difference" findings should not be read as proof that the techniques are equivalent.

