Bulk vs Incremental Thermoviscous Fills: 2-Year Class II RCT - EBIKO Dental Blog

A randomized split-mouth trial in the Journal of Dentistry found no statistically significant difference after two years between Class II restorations placed in 2-mm increments and those placed in 4-mm bulk increments, when both used preheated thermoviscous composites. Overall success was 95.9% for both techniques. It is one small trial with materials from a single manufacturer, so read it as a useful signal, not a settled answer.

Placement technique in Class II restorations is one of the oldest debates in restorative dentistry. As of November 2026, a new clinical trial adds data to it. The study, led by researchers in the Department of Restorative Dentistry at São Paulo State University in Brazil, was published online on 12 November 2026 in the Journal of Dentistry (November 2026 issue, PMID 43020454). It asks a direct question: when a composite is preheated before placement, does it matter whether you build a Class II box in thin layers or in thick ones?

For practices in Toronto and across the GTA that place posterior composites every day, the answer bears on chair time and on how you train associates. Here is what the trial did, what it found, and where its limits sit.

What Did the Trial Test?

The design was a randomized split-mouth trial. According to the published abstract, 30 patients each received two Class II restorations, for 60 restorations in total. In each patient, one restoration was placed with an incremental technique and the other with a bulk-fill technique. Because each patient received both, differences in diet, hygiene and bite are shared across the two arms.

  • Incremental arm: VisCalor Universal (Voco), placed in 2-mm increments.
  • Bulk-fill arm: VisCalor Bulk (Voco), placed in 4-mm increments.
  • Preheating: both materials were preheated to 68°C using a dedicated infrared heating device.
  • Adhesive: a self-etching adhesive system, Futurabond U (Voco), was used for every restoration.

The authors describe both composites as thermoviscous resin composites. Two calibrated examiners scored the restorations using FDI World Dental Federation criteria at 7 days, 1 year and 2 years, and the data were analyzed with Fisher's exact test.

Two Placement Techniques, One Two-Year Result Incremental arm 2-mm increments Preheated to 68°C Same self-etch adhesive Bulk-fill arm 4-mm increments Preheated to 68°C Same self-etch adhesive 2 years: 95.9% overall success in both arms
In this split-mouth trial, 2-mm incremental and 4-mm bulk placement with preheated composites reached the same 95.9% overall success at two years.

What Did the Trial Find?

After two years, 25 of the 30 patients returned for recall, so 50 restorations were evaluated. The headline result: no statistically significant differences between the two techniques on any of the parameters the examiners scored.

  • Overall success: 95.9% for both techniques.
  • Functional scores: 96.67% of restorations in each group had acceptable overall functional scores. In each group, 3.33% were rated not acceptable for fracture and retention.
  • Fractures: minor material fractures were found in two restorations per group, and all were successfully repaired.
  • Esthetics and biology: every restoration was rated esthetically and biologically acceptable.

The authors conclude that bulk-fill placement "can be considered a viable alternative" to incremental placement in Class II restorations when thermoviscous composites are used, without compromising clinical performance over the two-year period.

Why Does This Matter for Your Practice?

Incremental layering takes more steps per restoration. If a bulk technique performs the same in a given material system, that is time you can give back to the schedule. That is the practical reason this question keeps returning.

The finding is narrower than it may look, though. It applies to one material family, preheated with one type of device and bonded with one adhesive. It does not tell you how other bulk-fill composites perform, or how the same composites perform without preheating. Treat it as evidence about this system, not a general licence to bulk-fill every posterior box.

Pro Tip: If you are thinking about changing your Class II technique, follow the manufacturer's instructions for your exact material: increment depth, preheating, and curing time. The trial worked within a defined protocol, and its results only carry over if your protocol matches.

What Are the Trial's Limits?

A balanced reading needs the caveats as much as the result.

  • Small sample: 30 patients and 60 restorations at baseline, falling to 25 patients and 50 restorations at two years. Small trials can miss real differences, so "no significant difference" is not the same as "proven equal."
  • Short follow-up: two years is early for posterior composites. Longer recalls would show whether the arms stay level.
  • One manufacturer: both composites and the adhesive come from Voco. The results say nothing directly about other brands.
  • Abstract-level reading: the full text is behind a subscription. This summary is based on the published abstract and indexing record, so details such as funding, cavity size, operator experience and tooth distribution are not covered here.

What Should Canadian Practices Check Before Changing Materials?

The authors are based in Brazil, and the study does not address availability in Canada. Before you buy any material named in a study, confirm its licensing status with Health Canada. Health Canada's Medical Devices Active Licence Listing (MDALL) is a searchable public database. Ask your supplier for the licence details if you cannot find a product there.

It is also worth checking your existing inventory before adding a new system. Your practice may already stock a bulk-fill composite with its own published increment depth. A single trial like this one is a reason to review the evidence for the material you already use, not a reason to switch brands on its own.

You can find restorative supplies, bonding agents and hand instruments at EBIKO Dental.

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is bulk-fill as good as incremental layering for Class II composites?

This one trial found no statistically significant difference for the materials it tested. Preheated thermoviscous composites placed in 4-mm or 2-mm increments both reached 95.9% overall success at two years. The trial was small and used one manufacturer's products, so it does not settle the question for all bulk-fill composites.

Q: What temperature were the composites preheated to in the study?

Both composites were preheated to 68°C using a dedicated infrared heating device, according to the published abstract. Follow your own material's instructions rather than copying a study protocol.

Q: Are the composites in this trial available in Canada?

The study does not say. Check the product's licence in Health Canada's Medical Devices Active Licence Listing, or ask your supplier for the licence details, before purchasing.

EBIKO Dental will continue monitoring restorative research and report on new trials as they are published.

Dental-industry-trends, Practice-owners, Restorative-dentistry

Laisser un commentaire

Tous les commentaires sont modérés avant d'être publiés