BioFlex vs Steel Crowns With the Hall Technique: New RCT - EBIKO Dental Blog

A randomized controlled trial from Alexandria University found no statistically significant difference in 12-month success between tooth-coloured BioFlex crowns and stainless steel crowns placed with the Hall Technique on primary molars (91.9% vs 94.6%). Children and parents reported higher satisfaction with BioFlex, but the only crown perforations in the trial occurred in the BioFlex group, and the authors call for careful case selection and longer follow-up.

As of November 2026, the Hall Technique is an established conservative approach to caries in primary molars, and the trial authors describe the stainless steel crown (SSC) as the preferred material for it. The trade-off, they note, is a metallic appearance that raises aesthetic concerns for parents. A new trial, published online on October 22, 2026 in Clinical Oral Investigations (volume 30, issue 11), puts a tooth-coloured alternative to the test. For pediatric and family practices in Toronto and across the GTA, the results are worth a close read, along with their limits.

What did the trial compare?

The study, led by Yousra Ramadan with Marwa Baraka, Jeffrey A. Dean and Nadia A. Wahba, compared BioFlex crowns (BFCs) with conventional SSCs, both placed using the Hall Technique (HT). The authors are affiliated with the Department of Pediatric Dentistry and Dental Public Health at Alexandria University's Faculty of Dentistry in Egypt, and the Departments of Pediatric Dentistry and Orthodontics at the Indiana University School of Dentistry.

The paper describes BFCs as tooth-coloured crowns fabricated from a hybrid resin polymer material. The BFCs used in the trial were from NuSmile (Houston), and the SSCs were from 3M ESPE.

Key design points, as reported in the paper:

  • Participants: 74 healthy children aged 4 to 6 years, each contributing one mandibular second primary molar with caries scored ICDAS 3 to 5.
  • Allocation: two-arm parallel-group trial, 1:1 randomization (37 per group), computer-generated list with block randomization and sealed opaque envelopes.
  • Setting and timing: single centre (the outpatient clinic of the Alexandria department), with recruitment and data collection between August 2024 and August 2025.
  • Procedure: orthodontic separators were placed when needed, with crown seating at a second visit 3 to 5 days later. Caries was not removed, and crowns were cemented with resin-modified glass ionomer.
  • Follow-up: clinical checks at 1 week and 1, 3, 6 and 12 months; radiographs at 6 and 12 months. No participants were lost to follow-up.

One detail matters for anyone thinking of adopting this in practice. The authors state that, according to the manufacturer's recommendations, BFCs are not currently indicated for use with the Hall Technique, and they describe their use in the trial as off-label.

What did the trial find?

Both crowns performed well over one year, and the differences between them were not statistically significant.

  • Clinical success at 12 months: 34 of 37 BFCs (91.9%) and 35 of 37 SSCs (94.6%); relative risk 0.97 (95% CI 0.86 to 1.10).
  • Perforation: occurred only in the BFC group, 1 of 37 at 6 months and 2 of 37 at 12 months. No SSC perforated. The difference was not statistically significant.
  • Crown loss: 2 of 37 SSCs at 6 and 12 months, and 1 of 37 BFCs at 12 months, again with no significant difference.
  • Major failures: none in either group. The paper defined major failure as irreversible pulpitis, fistula or abscess requiring pulp therapy or extraction.
  • Soft tissue and plaque: SSCs had a higher gingival index at 1 week, while BFCs showed higher plaque scores at 6 and 12 months.
  • Satisfaction: child satisfaction favoured BFCs, and parents rated BFCs higher for colour and overall satisfaction.
12-Month Outcomes: BioFlex vs Stainless Steel (Hall Technique) Counts out of 37 crowns per group, as reported by Ramadan et al., 2026 BioFlex Stainless steel Clinical success 34/37 (91.9%) 35/37 (94.6%) Crown perforation 2/37 0/37 Crown loss 1/37 2/37
Success rates were similar at one year; none of the differences shown reached statistical significance, and only BioFlex crowns perforated.

Why the perforations matter more than the headline number

A 2.7-point gap in success that is not statistically significant is easy to read as "equivalent." The authors do not frame it that way. They flag that perforation occurred exclusively in the BFC group, which they suggest may indicate a material-specific vulnerability to occlusal wear compared with metal crowns. They also report that the affected children frequently ate hard foods such as popcorn, and they suggest BFCs may be less suitable for children with high masticatory demands.

The figures in the paper show progressive occlusal wear on a BFC across the follow-up period. The authors also note that the risk of perforation may increase beyond one year, and that the long-term implications of perforation for restoration longevity and pulpal health remain uncertain.

Their practical reading: BFCs may be a reasonable option for teeth that need short- to medium-term coverage, such as uncooperative patients with aesthetic concerns or primary teeth nearing exfoliation, rather than restorations expected to function for a long time.

Pro Tip: If your practice is weighing tooth-coloured crowns for primary molars, add one question to your parent consultation: how long the tooth needs to last before exfoliation. The trial's own authors tie their recommendation to that timeline.

How much weight should a Canadian practice give this trial?

It is a randomized trial with complete follow-up, but the authors list several limitations that shape how far the result travels:

  • Short follow-up. Twelve months may not reflect long-term durability.
  • Narrow population. Only healthy, cooperative children aged 4 to 6 with mandibular second primary molars were included, at a single centre. The authors caution that results may not extend to younger or older children, children with behaviour management difficulties, or other teeth.
  • No blinding. The two crowns look different, so neither operators nor families could be blinded, which the authors say could have introduced bias in satisfaction and clinical assessments.
  • Retrospective registration. The trial was registered at ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT06847646) on February 19, 2025, after recruitment began in August 2024. The authors acknowledge the registry record did not fully specify some methodological details.
  • Off-label use. As noted above, the manufacturer does not currently indicate BFCs for the Hall Technique.

For clinicians in Ontario, the off-label point deserves attention. If you consider a device outside its labelled indications, explain that plainly to families as part of consent. Before ordering any crown system that is new to your practice, confirm its Health Canada medical device licensing status and read the current instructions for use.

Pro Tip: Record the crown type, lot number and the parent's stated aesthetic preference in the chart at placement. If a perforation shows up at a 6-month recall, you will want that history in front of you.

What this means for pediatric care in the GTA

The trial does not displace the stainless steel crown. What it adds is early, randomized evidence that a tooth-coloured option can perform comparably over one year, at the cost of more plaque and a perforation signal that has not yet been tested over longer periods. When parents in Mississauga, Markham or Scarborough ask about alternatives to metal crowns, this is a trial practitioners can discuss with them, along with its caveats.

EBIKO Dental will continue monitoring longer-term follow-up on aesthetic crowns for primary molars and will report on new trials as they are published. For dental supplies and clinical news written for Canadian practices, visit EBIKO Dental.

Sources

  • Ramadan Y, Baraka M, Dean JA, Wahba NA. Clinical and radiographic success of bioflex versus stainless steel crowns using the hall technique in primary molars: a 12-month randomized controlled trial. Clinical Oral Investigations. 2026;30(11). doi:10.1007/s00784-026-07156-4 (open access via Europe PMC)
  • ClinicalTrials.gov registration: NCT06847646

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Are tooth-coloured crowns as successful as stainless steel crowns with the Hall Technique?

In one 2026 randomized trial of 74 children, 12-month success was 91.9% for BioFlex crowns and 94.6% for stainless steel crowns, a difference that was not statistically significant. The authors caution that the follow-up was short and that perforations occurred only in the BioFlex group.

Q: Is BioFlex indicated for the Hall Technique?

According to the trial authors, the manufacturer's recommendations do not currently indicate BioFlex crowns for use with the Hall Technique, and the study used them off-label. Check the current instructions for use and Health Canada licensing status before adopting any crown system.

Q: Which children might suit a BioFlex crown, according to the study?

The authors suggest BioFlex crowns may suit teeth needing short- to medium-term coverage, such as primary teeth nearing exfoliation or uncooperative patients with aesthetic concerns. They suggest they may be less suitable for children with strong bite forces or diets with hard or abrasive foods.

Dental-industry-trends, Preventive-care, Restorative-dentistry

Leave a comment

All comments are moderated before being published